Is Asphalt or Concrete Cheaper? Cost Comparison from City Service Asphalt
Homeowners planning a new driveway often ask the same question: is asphalt or concrete cheaper?
At first glance, both options can look similar, but the cost, maintenance, and long-term performance of these two paving materials vary significantly.
This guide breaks down the real-world differences between asphalt and concrete, including installation, repairs, and long-term value.
By the end, you’ll understand which option makes sense for your driveway, parking lots, or residential project — and why choosing asphalt is often the more affordable option.
Key Takeaways
Asphalt driveways typically cost less per square foot than a concrete driveway
Concrete has higher upfront cost and longer cure times
Asphalt is more flexible and easier to repair
In most cases, asphalt offers a lower overall cost
Proper maintenance helps both materials last longer, but asphalt repairs are simpler
Table of Contents
Cost Comparison: Asphalt vs Concrete
Installation Costs
The most immediate difference between asphalt vs concrete is installation price. On average, asphalt driveways are more cheaper to install than a concrete driveway, especially when measured per square foot.
A typical average asphalt driveway requires fewer materials, faster installation, and less labour. Concrete, on the other hand, involves cement, sand, stone, and additional construction steps, increasing the total cost.
The going rate for asphalt is generally lower per square foot, making it a more affordable option for homeowners with larger driveway size or limited budgets.
Maintenance and Repairs
Over time, maintenance plays a major role in the overall cost. Concrete surfaces are often marketed as low maintenance, but when cracks appear, repairs can be expensive and visually obvious.
Asphalt surfaces are easier to maintain, and repairs such as filling cracks or resurfacing are faster and less costly. With proper maintenance, an asphalt driveway can perform reliably for decades.
Unlike concrete, asphalt repairs blend into the existing surface, keeping a consistent appearance and reducing long-term cost.
Durability and Climate Impact
Climate matters. Asphalt and concrete react differently in hot climates, cold climate regions, and areas with freezing temperatures.
Concrete expands and contracts more in cold weather, increasing the risk of crumbling and surface cracks. Asphalt, by contrast, remains more flexible, handling freeze thaw cycles better.
In hot weather, concrete can reflect heat, while blacktop absorbs it, helping snow and ice melt faster in colder regions where salt is used.
Choosing the Right Material
When comparing asphalt or concrete, it’s important to consider more than just upfront price. Think about:
Installation timeline
Future maintenance
Repair frequency
Long-term durability
For many homeowners, choosing asphalt offers a balance of durable performance, lower cost, and faster completion — often within seven days from start to finish.
City Service Asphalt
City Service Asphalt helps homeowners and property managers select the right material for their driveway, parking lots, and paving project.
By evaluating soil, depth, usage, and climate factors, City Service Asphalt delivers complete solutions that prioritise value, performance, and long-term savings — making asphalt the more affordable option in most cases.
Final Thoughts
While both asphalt and concrete have different benefits, asphalt consistently offers lower cost, easier repairs, and quicker installation.
For homeowners replacing an old driveway or planning a new driveway, asphalt is often the smarter investment.
If you’re weighing asphalt vs concrete and want a clear recommendation based on your house, usage, and budget, professional guidance can make all the difference.
Get a Free Quote to discuss your paving project with City Service Asphalt.
FAQs
Is asphalt or concrete better for driveways?
In most cases, asphalt is more affordable, easier to repair, and better suited for varying weather conditions.
Does concrete last longer than asphalt?
Concrete can last longer in ideal conditions, but higher cost and complex repairs often offset this benefit.
Which material has lower maintenance costs?
Asphalt generally requires less maintenance and lower-cost repairs compared to concrete.
Can asphalt handle heavy vehicles?
Yes, when properly compacted and installed to the correct depth, asphalt handles residential traffic well.
Is asphalt environmentally friendly?
Modern asphalt uses recycled materials and can be resurfaced instead of replaced, reducing waste.
CITY SERVICE ASPHALT
Reliable paving, sealcoating, and repair experts serving Corona, Riverside, and Orange County. Providing long-lasting asphalt solutions built to withstand California’s weather.
GET IN TOUCH
769 Beverely Road, Corona CA 92879
